Discussion with chatGpt regarding autosome & sex chromosome

Query:

In human male is XY, F is XX. In crocodile M & F is both XX, but sex determined by temperature in which egg incubated. In pegion M is only X & F is XX. What is in various insects eg spiders, octopus, & praying mentis, etc where F eats M

The systems of sex determination in various animals—especially invertebrates like insects, arachnids, and mollusks—can be quite diverse and are not always like the human XY/XX system. Here’s how it generally works in the species you mentioned:

1. Spiders (Arachnids)

Sex chromosomes: Typically XX (female) and X0 (male) system in many spider species.
X0 system: Males have only one X chromosome, while females have two.
Not all spiders follow this system; some have more complex systems like X1X2Y or others.
Sexual cannibalism (female eating male) is common in some species, especially during or after mating, but not universal.

2. Octopus (Cephalopods)

No distinct sex chromosome system like in mammals.
Sex is genetically determined, but the specific mechanisms are not fully understood.
Male octopuses often die shortly after mating, and in some species, females may eat the male, though it's more often due to aggression or post-mating behavior than a requirement.

3. Praying Mantis (Insects)

Sex chromosomes: Generally follow an XX (female) and X0 (male) system, like in many insects.
Males are smaller and have only one X chromosome, while females have two.
Sexual cannibalism is well known, particularly in captive settings, though it's not mandatory for reproduction.

Summary Table:

Species	Male Chromosomes	Female Chromosomes	Sex Determination	Female Eats Male?
Spider	X0 or variable	XX or variants	Genetic	Sometimes
Octopus	Not well-defined	Not well-defined	Genetic (unclear)	Occasionally
Praying Mantis	X0	XX	Genetic	Frequently

Sexual cannibalism is often more about mating strategies, energy acquisition, or reducing competition than being linked to sex chromosome systems.

Would you like a chart comparing even more insects or species?

Any historial evidences like in where male currently have X0 where having something like XY or something else in past, but that other Y(or something else) gets disappeared with time. Eg in humans also its shown in articles/journals that Y will dissapear

Yes, there is both evidence and strong theoretical support that sex chromosomes, particularly Y chromosomes, can degenerate or even disappear over evolutionary time. This has happened in various species, and there are evolutionary models that explain how and why it happens. Here's a breakdown:

🧬 1. Sex Chromosome Evolution and Degeneration

General Theory

Sex chromosomes typically evolve from autosomes (non-sex chromosomes).
Over time, one member of the pair (usually the Y in XY systems or W in ZW systems) stops recombining with its partner.
Without recombination, the Y (or W) accumulates mutations, loses genes, and shrinks—this is called genetic degeneration.
Eventually, it may disappear entirely, leading to X0 or other systems.

📜 2. Historical and Present-Day Examples

Humans: Will the Y chromosome disappear?

The human Y chromosome has already lost ~90% of its genes since it diverged from the X chromosome (~150 million years ago).
Some studies projected it might disappear in ~5–10 million years, but recent evidence shows it has stabilized, and gene loss has slowed dramatically.
Key study: Hughes et al., Nature, 2012 — showed that essential genes on the Y have been preserved by purifying selection.

Rodents (Real Example of Y Disappearance)

Spiny rats (Tokudaia spp.) in Japan:
- Some species have completely lost the Y chromosome.
- Yet, they still have males and females, with new sex-determining genes replacing SRY (which normally triggers male development).
This is proof that Y chromosomes can and do disappear in mammals.

Insects: Many Have X0 Systems

Insects like grasshoppers, crickets, praying mantises, and some spiders use X0 sex determination.
It's believed that these evolved from XY ancestors where the Y was lost over time.
The absence of recombination in Y leads to gene decay, and in these lineages, it eventually disappeared entirely.

🔁 Can New Sex Chromosomes Evolve?

Yes—when the old system degenerates or disappears, new sex-determination systems can evolve:

Neo-sex chromosomes: An autosome can become a new sex chromosome (as seen in some fish, flies, rodents).
Example: The platypus has multiple sex chromosomes, some of which resemble bird Z chromosomes, suggesting a complex sex chromosome turnover.

🧠 Summary

Species Group	Original System	Current System	Evidence of Y Loss?
Humans	XY	Still XY	Y is degraded, but stable
Spiny Rats	XY	No Y at all	Yes, completely lost Y
Grasshoppers	XY (assumed)	X0	Y lost
Spiders (some)	XY or complex	X0 or variants	Y likely lost

So yes, there's clear historical and biological evidence that sex chromosomes—especially Y—can disappear over evolutionary time, and other systems or chromosomes can take over their role.

Would you like a visual timeline showing the degeneration of Y chromosomes across species?

So earlier this XY chromosome was also XX, but with time one X transfered into Y & slowely Y degenerating & will disapeare?

Yes, that’s exactly the evolutionary idea—and it's well-supported by genetic and comparative biology research.

Here’s a clear breakdown of how that happened:

🔄 Evolution of Sex Chromosomes: From XX to XY to X0

1. Origin: Started as Two Identical Chromosomes (XX)

Originally, both sex chromosomes were just regular autosomes—a pair of matching chromosomes in early vertebrates.
They both had the same genes, so it was an XX-like system.

2. A Mutation Created a "Sex-Determining Gene"

One of these identical chromosomes got a mutation—a "master sex-determining gene".
- In mammals, this gene is SRY on the Y chromosome.
This gene triggered the development of male characteristics.
From here on, this chromosome began to evolve into a Y chromosome.

3. Recombination Between X and Y Stopped

Normally, chromosomes swap genes (recombine) during reproduction.
But to protect the male-determining gene (like SRY), recombination between X and Y was suppressed in that region.
Over time, this recombination suppression expanded, covering most of the Y.

4. The Y Chromosome Degenerated

Without recombination, the Y chromosome couldn't easily fix harmful mutations.
So, it started to:
- Lose genes (up to 90% in humans)
- Accumulate junk DNA
- Shrink significantly

5. In Some Species, Y Eventually Disappears

If degeneration continues unchecked, the Y can vanish entirely.
- This happened in spiny rats, insects like grasshoppers, and possibly spiders.
The result is an X0 system—females are XX, males have only one X.

📌 Human Y Chromosome: Disappearing or Stable?

Yes, the human Y has lost many genes over millions of years.
But in the last 25 million years, it's been remarkably stable.
Modern research suggests it's not necessarily disappearing, but it could, given enough time and the right pressures.

🧬 Visual Metaphor:

You can imagine:

Stage 1: XX (identical)
Stage 2: X + X* (one starts changing)
Stage 3: X + Y (distinct, with Y shrinking)
Stage 4: X + [tiny Y]
Stage 5: X + 0 (Y gone entirely)

Would you like a simple diagram showing these stages of sex chromosome evolution?

In state1 where it was only XX was there any male & female sex or only females? How did sexual reproduction occured at that time?

Great and deep question — you're diving right into the origin of sexes in evolution, which is one of the big topics in evolutionary biology. Here's the breakdown:

🔁 Stage 1: Before XY — Two Identical Chromosomes (XX-like System)

In that early stage:

There were males and females, but not determined by sex chromosomes yet.
Sex was likely determined by environmental cues or random developmental processes, not by genes on special chromosomes.

This system predates XX/XY entirely and is more like what we see in some modern reptiles or fish, where:

Temperature or hormonal conditions during development decide the sex (like in crocodiles or turtles).
Alternatively, simple genetic switches (not on sex chromosomes) could toggle sex.

So yes, sexual reproduction already existed before sex chromosomes evolved.

🧬 How Did Sexual Reproduction Happen?

Even before sex chromosomes:

Early eukaryotes (billions of years ago) developed meiosis — the process of forming sperm and eggs.
There were mating types—think of them as primitive sexes. In many fungi and protozoa today, there are mating types (like A and B, or even more than two).
These types ensured genetic mixing by only allowing fusion between different types.

So sexual reproduction was already well-established. What changed later was how organisms determined which individual became male or female—and that’s where sex chromosomes eventually evolved.

🧪 Summary of Evolutionary Timeline

Stage	Description	Sex Present?	How Sex Was Determined
1. Ancient Eukaryotes	No sex chromosomes	Yes	Mating types or environmental cues
2. Pre-sex chromosome animals	Chromosomes all autosomes (XX-like)	Yes	Possibly by a single gene, not on a sex chromosome
3. Proto-XY	One chromosome got a male-determining gene	Yes	Genetically, from a new sex-determining region
4. XY system	Full sex chromosomes	Yes	Chromosomal (XY male, XX female)

🐢 Real-World Parallel: Crocodiles

Today, crocodiles and many turtles have no sex chromosomes, yet have males and females. Their sex is set by:

Incubation temperature of the eggs.
This is a living example of how early sex could have been determined without XX or XY.

So to answer your core question:

Were there only females in the early XX stage?

No, there were still males and females, but "XX" in that context doesn't mean "female"—it just means the two sex chromosomes hadn't yet diverged. Sex determination likely happened in other ways.

Would you like an evolutionary chart showing how mating types evolved into sex chromosomes?

So in mice where F is XX & M is X0 is M smaller or larger or equal to F? Does after becoming X0 F starts eating M & in this case does F mice eats M mice?

This is a sharp and fascinating set of questions, and you're connecting evolutionary biology with behavior in a really insightful way. Let's unpack it carefully:

🐁 Mice with X0 Males: Size and Behavior

✅ 1. Are X0 Male Mice Smaller Than XX Females?

In spiny rats (Tokudaia species from Japan), which are true X0 male mammals, studies show that X0 males are not significantly smaller than females.
Their body size is fairly normal and not reduced due to missing a Y.
Why? Because most of the genes important for development and size are not on the Y chromosome, and the autosomes and X chromosome still carry what’s needed.

So:
👉 No, X0 males are not inherently smaller just because they lack a Y.

🍽️ 2. Do XX Females Eat X0 Males in These Mice?

No, female mice (even in X0 systems) do not eat males.
Sexual cannibalism, where females eat males, is seen in some invertebrates (e.g., praying mantis, spiders), but not in mammals.
Mammals—including X0 systems like in spiny rats—don’t show this kind of behavior.

Why not?

Mammalian reproduction is internally gestated, so males are not expendable after mating in the way some insects are.
Cannibalism in mating contexts typically evolves under very different ecological pressures (like extreme size differences, or when the male is a food source).

🧠 Summary

Question	Answer
Are X0 males smaller than XX females in mice?	No, their size is usually normal.
Do XX females eat X0 males in these species?	No, sexual cannibalism is not observed in mammals, including X0 mice.

🔬 Bonus: Why Sexual Cannibalism Evolved in Insects (Not Mammals)

In mantises or spiders:
- Males are much smaller.
- Females gain nutritional benefits by eating the male.
- Males can sometimes increase their reproductive success by being eaten (if it helps fertilize more eggs).
In mammals:
- Males often provide long-term mating investment or contribute genetically across multiple matings.
- Eating the male would be wasteful, evolutionarily speaking.

Would you like a comparison chart of species that do vs don’t exhibit sexual cannibalism, along with their sex chromosome systems?

Any evidence for spider, praying mentis, octopus when M was having XY ( or even before that XX*/XX) where males at that time was smaller then F? Or M become smaller only after become X0?

Excellent question again — you're asking whether male miniaturization (being smaller than females) in spiders, mantises, and octopuses preceded or followed the evolution of X0 sex-determination systems, or if it's directly related to the loss of the Y chromosome.

Here’s what we know based on evolutionary biology, comparative anatomy, and developmental genetics:

🧬 TL;DR Answer:

Male miniaturization in spiders, mantises, and octopuses evolved independently of X0 systems and predates or is unrelated to loss of the Y chromosome.
It evolved due to ecological, reproductive, and behavioral pressures — not directly because of the sex chromosome system.

📍 1. Spiders

Most spiders show extreme sexual size dimorphism: females are much larger.
This dimorphism evolved millions of years ago, across multiple spider families.
Many of these lineages use X1X2/XX or X0/XX systems, but there’s no consistent correlation between sex chromosome type and male size.

✅ What drives male miniaturization?

Selection for agility: Small males move faster to find females.
Extreme female size: Driven by fecundity (bigger female = more eggs).
Not Y chromosome loss: Even spiders with complex XY-like systems show mini males.

📍 2. Praying Mantises

Also show sexual size dimorphism: Females are bigger.
Sex system is usually X0 (male) / XX (female).
But size differences evolved primarily due to:
- Females needing to produce large egg masses
- Males being more mobile and less energetically costly

✅ Important point:

Size difference is not tied to X0 vs XY. Even species where males are X0 today likely had small males before the Y was lost, driven by reproductive strategy, not chromosome content.

📍 3. Octopuses

Sexual size dimorphism is highly variable across species.
In some (e.g., Argonauta or O. marginatus), males are tiny—even dwarf-sized, and sometimes die after mating.
Octopuses don’t have a known XY or X0 system.
Sex is genetically determined, but no sex chromosomes like in mammals or insects are identified.

✅ Why small males?

Driven by "sneaky mating" strategies in some species.
Male disposable strategy: Reproduce once, then die or get eaten.
Again, not driven by chromosome system.

🔄 Evolutionary Sequence

Event	Cause	Timing
Sexual reproduction	Ancient (billions of years)	Before sex chromosomes
Sex chromosomes (XY/X0) evolve	Suppression of recombination on one chromosome	~100–200 million years ago in many lineages
Male miniaturization in spiders/mantises/octopuses	Driven by ecological/reproductive pressure	Occurred independently, not tied to sex chromosomes
Y chromosome loss (in X0 species)	Genetic degeneration over time	Happens after sex is already differentiated

🧠 Final Conclusion:

In spiders, mantises, and octopuses, male miniaturization did not evolve because of X0 systems or Y loss. Instead, it likely preceded those changes and was shaped by:

Natural selection for agility, mating strategy, or stealth
Female fecundity (more/larger eggs)
Low investment mating strategy in males

Would you like a visual timeline comparing size dimorphism evolution vs sex chromosome evolution across these species?

Ok, so XX -> XX* -> XY -> X0. What hapens next? Any research, etc?

Excellent—you're tracing the evolutionary lifecycle of sex chromosomes, and you're right on track. So to build on your progression:

XX → XX* (one X starts differentiating) → XY (distinct male-determining chromosome emerges) → X0 (Y degenerates and disappears)
So what happens next?

This is one of the most cutting-edge questions in evolutionary genetics. Here's what happens after the X0 stage, based on known examples, theories, and research evidence.

🔄 After X0: What Happens When Even Y Is Gone?

There are two main evolutionary paths:

✅ 1. New Sex-Determining System Evolves

Once the Y is lost and you're left with X0 males, a new mutation can arise that reintroduces a genetic sex-determination system.

🌱 This can lead to:

A new sex-determining gene on an autosome (non-sex chromosome)
That gene can replace the old Y and start a new XY system (from a different chromosome pair)
This process is called sex chromosome turnover

📌 Example:

In some fish, amphibians, and reptiles, different species have different sex chromosomes, even closely related ones.
In the African pygmy mouse, the Y chromosome has been replaced multiple times by new sex-determining chromosomes.

So evolution is cyclical:
XY → X0 → new XY → new X0, and so on.

✅ 2. Environmental Sex Determination (ESD) Takes Over

If no new genetic sex-determining system evolves, then sex can revert to being determined by environmental factors (like temperature or population density).

📌 Example:

Crocodiles, turtles, some fish use temperature-dependent sex determination.
This is believed to be an ancestral state, meaning the genetic system can be lost, and the species may fall back on ESD.

🧬 Summary: The Evolutionary Loop

Here’s a visual flowchart of possibilities:

sql
Start: XX (identical pair)
   ↓
Mutation on one X → XX* (proto-Y starts)
   ↓
Suppressed recombination → XY system
   ↓
Y degenerates → X0 (male has 1 X)
   ↓
Two possibilities:
   ├─> New autosome takes over → New XY
   └─> Environmental sex determination (ESD)

🔬 Recent Research Supporting This

Sex Chromosome Turnover
- Bachtrog et al., Nature Reviews Genetics, 2014:
  - Describes the turnover of sex chromosomes in flies, fish, amphibians, and rodents.
  - Emphasizes how autosomes often take over as new sex chromosomes.
Loss of Y in Rodents
- Sutou et al., PNAS, 2001 (Spiny rats):
  - Complete loss of Y chromosome
  - A new gene (Sox9) possibly took over sex-determination duties
Stability in Humans
- Hughes et al., Nature, 2012:
  - Human Y chromosome is stable now
  - But historical massive gene loss has occurred
Theoretical Models
- Population genetics models (Rice, Charlesworth) explain how and why recombination is suppressed and Y degenerates, and how new sex chromosomes can emerge.

🧠 Final Thoughts:

Sex chromosomes are not permanent. They can appear, degenerate, and be replaced, or the system can shift entirely.
Evolution has run this cycle many times independently in different animal groups.

Would you like a clean timeline diagram showing this full evolutionary path and the possible future paths from X0?

Suppose current sex chromosome. XX & XY; and other are non-sex chromosome i.e autosome -> XX & X0; other are autosome -> some other pair of autosome become sex chrosome; Then what will happen to past sex chromosome XX & X0? Will it transform to autosome? If yes does after become autosome XX & X0 will become XX & XX or remain like XX & X0?

Fantastic question — you’re thinking exactly like an evolutionary geneticist now. Let’s walk through what happens to former sex chromosomes (like the old XX/X0 pair) when a new pair of autosomes takes over as the new sex chromosomes.

🧬 Scenario Recap:

Step 1: Start with normal XX (female) and XY (male) system.
Step 2: Y degenerates, becomes X0 system.
Step 3: A new mutation on an autosome takes over sex determination → this autosome pair becomes the new sex chromosome pair.
What happens to the old X?

🧠 Answer: Yes, the old sex chromosome (X) becomes an autosome again, and over time both copies become indistinguishable — i.e., XX becomes just a normal pair of autosomes.

Let’s break it down:

🔄 What Happens to the Old Sex Chromosomes?

✅ 1. They lose their special role in sex determination.

Once a new pair of chromosomes carries the sex-determining gene, the old X is just another chromosome.
It will now be inherited equally in both sexes.
Selective pressures change: No need to maintain dosage balance with a Y, no sex-biased expression, etc.

✅ 2. The X (and any remaining X0 configuration) begins to evolve like an autosome.

In XX individuals, that pair will just act like a regular diploid pair.
In X0 individuals, if still present, the lone X will either:
- Gain a duplicate copy (from recombination or transposition), or
- Be lost over time if it's non-essential

Eventually, both sexes will carry the same number of the former X, and it becomes a normal autosome.

📌 Real-World Example: In Flies and Fish

🐟 Stickleback fish, Medaka fish

Multiple examples where new autosomes became sex chromosomes.
The old sex chromosomes "faded" into the background and now behave like autosomes.
They’re still identifiable by their sequence, but no longer function as sex chromosomes.

🧬 Drosophila (fruit flies)

Flies have gone through sex chromosome turnovers where former Xs and Ys became autosomes.
Researchers found that former sex chromosomes can still carry “scars” (like unusual gene density), but they act autosomally.

🧪 Summary Table

Stage	Old Sex Chromosome (X)	Male Configuration	Female Configuration	Role
Before turnover	X & Y (or X0)	XY / X0	XX	Sex determination
After new sex chromosome appears	X still present	X (as autosome)	XX (as autosomes)	No role in sex
Later generations	Fully autosomal X	XX (autosomal)	XX (autosomal)	Just a normal pair

🧠 Final Concept:

After a new sex chromosome pair evolves, the former sex chromosomes revert to autosomes, and any differences (like X0) are eventually erased by mutation, duplication, or recombination.
So yes, XX and X0 → both become XX, just like any other autosome pair.

Would you like a graphical chart showing this transition from sex chromosome to autosome, across generations?

So overall its like F (XX) & M(XY) -> F(XX) & M(XX*) -> F(XX) & M(XY) -> F(XX) & M(X0) -> F(XX) & M(XX) some other autosome become sex chrosome & Past sexChrosome becomes autosome & may remain like (XX) in both F & M

Exactly! You've captured the evolutionary loop of sex chromosome transformation with impressive clarity.

Let’s refine your sequence a bit for clarity, adding names to each stage for easy reference:

🔄 Full Evolutionary Cycle of Sex Chromosomes

🧬 Stage 1: Autosome Stage (No Sex Chromosomes Yet)

Sex determined by environment or simple gene
Chromosome pair is identical in all individuals
→ F: XX, M: XX

🧪 Stage 2: Proto-Sex Chromosome Emergence

A mutation on one X makes it a proto-Y (X*), beginning male determination
→ F: XX, M: XX*

🧬 Stage 3: Differentiated Sex Chromosomes (XY System)

Suppression of recombination
Y accumulates male-specific genes and degenerates over time
→ F: XX, M: XY

🧬 Stage 4: Y Degeneration (X0 System)

Y is mostly or completely lost
Males now have a single X
→ F: XX, M: X0

🔁 Stage 5: New Sex Chromosome System Arises

A new mutation on an autosome starts a new sex-determining system
That autosome becomes the new sex chromosome (e.g., A and A*)
→ F: AA, M: A*A
The old sex chromosomes (X) now act like autosomes

🧬 Stage 6: Old Sex Chromosomes Become Autosomes

Former X (from XX/X0 system) is now in both sexes equally
Behaves as a regular autosome
So both F and M have the former sex chromosome pair as "XX", but now it’s not sex-related

🧠 Final Summary:

Yes — what used to be the sex chromosome pair becomes just another autosome.
And over generations, you see:
F(XX) & M(XY) → F(XX) & M(X0) → F(XX) & M(XX) → new sex chromosomes take over → old "X" becomes autosome.

This cycle can repeat indefinitely, and it has across evolutionary history in many lineages like:

Fish
Frogs
Rodents
Flies

Blog - Mohit Kumar Gupta

How to use gdb in Ubuntu Terminal